sinhasach.in · boot skip any key

A Day of Survival in Watts.

Walk one kilometre and you burn a third of a banana. A humanoid robot burns more than a whole one. Run both bodies through a day of survival and read the meter.

Walk to the end of your street and back. One kilometre, near enough.

Your step counter calls that a decent effort. Your body calls it a third of a banana. About 33 kilocalories. You could do it eight times running, with something heavy in between each if you were feeling smug, on fuel you’re already carrying around your middle.

Now send a humanoid robot on the same walk. It burns about 115 kilocalories.

A whole banana, plus a bit, for something you did on a third of one.

Last time I promised the meter wouldn’t read 80 for the machine. I’ve just thrown a number at you, and I’ve read enough cost reports to know that a number without working is a rumour. So here’s the working.

The number nobody explains

Engineers measure how efficiently anything moves with a single figure called the cost of transport: the energy you burn carrying your own weight over a distance, divided by that weight and that distance. The units cancel, which is the whole trick. A mouse, a person and a lorry all land on the same scale.

For a person walking, it’s 0.2.

For today’s humanoid robots, a recent survey of the field says above 0.7.

Same scale. Same job. At least three and a half times the bill.

Here’s the formula, so you can check me: power equals cost of transport, times mass, times gravity, times speed. Take a 70 kilogram body at a brisk 1.4 metres a second. You come out at about 190 watts. A robot of the same weight comes out at about 670.

Now go back to part 1. I charged a survival day about 170 watts for the effort of staying alive, on top of the 80 you burn sitting still. That is, give or take, brisk walking with extras.

Here’s the surprise. The physics barely cares about the tools. Digging, lifting, swinging a hammer, all small change next to the daily business of hauling your own body about. A machine that can’t do that cheaply has lost the day before it picks anything up.

Not everyone is 70 kilograms

Part 1 quietly used an average adult, and I should own that. People come in more than one size, and the formula has mass in it.

Women burn fewer calories than men for the same day’s work, and the reason isn’t the one most people assume. Run the walk again for a tall, lean woman, 1.78 metres and 66 kilograms. Same cost of transport, same speed, a little less body to carry: about 181 watts instead of 192. Six percent cheaper, and nobody’s metabolism did anything clever.

The engine isn’t cheaper. There’s just less of it to run. Per kilogram of lean tissue, resting rates come out essentially the same, and a study of 2,326 adults measured with doubly labelled water found adjusted total energy expenditure similar between the sexes. The standard dietitian equation still leaves a woman about 166 kilocalories a day below a man of identical weight, height and age, so it isn’t only size, but most of it is.

For a woman of that build, I’d shave 5 to 10 percent off part 1’s headline numbers: about 75 watts at rest and 235 on a survival day. A ballpark, not a measurement. It also leaves out the one variable the formula doesn’t have, tenacity, which I’ve seen move the answer more than any term it does.

Robots obey the same rule. Unitree’s H1 weighs about 47 kilograms, so at that same 0.7 it pays about 77 kilocalories a kilometre, not 115. Smaller is cheaper. Nature worked this out some time ago, and the formula has no opinion about anyone. It only knows mass.

A day on foot

Say a hard survival day covers 20 kilometres. That’s my number, so treat it as round. For the 70 kilogram reference human, it costs about 0.76 kilowatt hours. Call it 660 kilocalories, a decent lunch.

For the robot: 2.7 kilowatt hours.

Unitree’s H1, a lighter robot, carries an 864 watt hour battery. At that same 0.7 it’s flat in under 10 kilometres, and it hasn’t built a single shelter.

The spec sheets are kinder, because they measure kinder work. Agility’s Digit is reported to carry 16 kilograms, one ordinary kettlebell, so machines like it are moving totes, not building shelters. And the runtime on a spec sheet is the “up to” kind, like the broadband adverts, achieved on a smooth floor with a following wind.

Boston Dynamics publishes two runtimes for Atlas: four hours, or two with heavy lifting. Same pack, half the time. That’s my arithmetic, not theirs, but it says heavy work draws roughly double.

So the spec sheets describe a light day. A real one lands at 600 watts and up, before we’ve even switched the computer on.

The fuel problem

At 600 watts, a day costs 14.4 kilowatt hours. The best generic lithium ion cells hold about 243 watt hours per kilogram.

That’s 59 kilograms of battery. For one day.

A backpack you’d need a second robot to carry, which would need a battery of its own, and so on until you’re running a logistics company. Atlas, with everything in it, weighs 90.

Your equivalent is half a kilo of body fat. Fat holds about 10,556 watt hours per kilogram, 43 times those cells. Your body wastes most of it as heat, which is the fifth that becomes work, so the useful advantage drops to about ten times. Still ten, and I’ve been generous to the battery by ignoring its own losses.

Atlas swaps its battery in three minutes and recharges in an hour and a half. Remarkable engineering. Now find the wall socket.

So the body is a disaster, and the people building these machines know it. Their answer is usually the same: forget the body, the mind is where the machine wins.

Fair enough. Next time, I check.

Next: The Cheapest Computer in the Building.


Sources and the ballpark

Every figure above is rounded. The robot wattages are my arithmetic on published numbers, not measurements. My own assumptions are a 70 kilogram reference body, a 66 kilogram, 1.78 metre woman, a walking speed of 1.4 metres a second, a 20 kilometre day, and a banana of about 105 kilocalories.

Also on Medium. Corrections welcome at sach@sinhasach.in.

NORMAL the-80-watt-animal ~/sinhasach.in/writing/the-80-watt-animal/a-day-of-survival-in-watts utf-8 unix terminal 0%